-The start felt lousy in person...but if Purdue starts off that flat v. UND, they'll be down by 14 before they can say "overmatched".
-OJ Ross' fumble was completely avoidable...but honestly, it's amazing he doesn't lose more fumbles with his lack of ball security. His arm seems to get farther away from his body the longer the run goes...clearly he has great vision and acceleration, but he must work on how he holds the ball...if only there was some sort of advisor or coach that could tell him this.
-I watched the two "dirty" hits (one from Purdue, one from SEMO) that resulted in 15 yard penalties multiple times...and I still don't agree with either flag. Neither player led with their head, both had their eyes up and both finished the hit by extending their arms. Football is a brutal game, these were good, clean, hard hits. Referees seem to throw flags based on how a player hits the ground, not based on the nature of the hit too often.
-On a related note, Marve should have thrown the ball to Edison earlier...it would have saved 13 from that shot...On the play, Marve felt like the pocket was collapsing, and it actually wasn't. Perhaps he'll feel more comfortable with reps.
-Marve clearly favors his donor knee still. That said, when he scrambled and plays broke down a bit, he had no limp...While I'm positive he's still a bit sore, I think much of that comes from his logical fear of getting injured again and wanting to protect himself. Once again, reps should help him feel more comfortable.
-Both TerBush and Marve looked as good on the replay as they did in person. BUT, SEMO was clearly waaaaaay past respectful to Purdue's receivers and were giving too much cushion. I might have been able to complete a few passes versus that kind of space.
But, Nord was smart enough to recognize the quick passes would shred that defense and he exploited it. The screens worked because of that space, sit-down routes were the same way...TerBush and Marve both delivered with ease.
-There is, and will be, a debate about who should start and who will start. Since our Boilers are probably just doing conditioning, lifting and getting healthy the next few days, there will be no evaluation. But when they return to practice, there will still be a ton of practice time for the coaches to get educated on who should be starting.
That said, I think it should be Marve's job.
Let's not forget, he was the first stringer last season before the rash of injuries...and would have been #1 had his knee healed faster...even still was ahead of TerBush coming into camp. Now that he's healthy, he's the deserved starter. He makes decisions faster, even without playing in any games, he has a faster release, is extremely accurate, and has a cannon of an arm. Plus, like Rob Henry, Marve seems to command the huddle and line of scrimmage with more confidence...I think lineman and everyone else feed off of that.
TerBush still floats the ball a bit and seems to over think every play. If Purdue had to start TerBush, I'm positive he'd develop...he already has. But I hope to see Marve starting v. UND...but I don't make the final call (obviously).
![]() |
Too easy. |
-Bolden looked unimpressive at times. Maybe it was because his head wasn't in the right place, but to me, he was less-impressive on the re-watch than in person. In fact, if I had never seen him play before, I'd guess he wasn't even on the depth chart as he was overshadowed by about everybody else who ran the ball.
I'm positive this was the exception, not the new rule...and I want 23 starting...but the mental focus has to be there. Plus, the tweak of his hammy probably didn't help much.
-Edison was playing in a higher gear than everyone on the field all day.
-Bruce Gaston and Will Lucas play angry at times...I like that.
-KK Short is a big, strong, ugly, sexy beast.
-Joe Holland lined up at end a few times in passing downs...I'm positive that was because of my suggestion following the Rice game. Glad to see my good ideas don't go to waste.
-Johnson and Allen clearly terrified SEMO's QB (with the exception of the first play of the game). SEMO was right to be afraid.
-Just as scary as the corners looked, the safeties seem that un-frightening. There's work to be done back there, and believe it or not, even with the lopsided score, the safeties missed some opportunities. I like the way Evans plays more than any of them, but he's still not playing like he was prior to his injury in '10. When Purdue's not in a nickel, I'd like to see Harris and Evans or Charlot back there.
-Ryan Russell was more impressive in this game than any other thus far...it could be because he was bigger, stronger and faster than the guy across from him...by a lot.
-There's a ton of work to be done. This was a fun vacation from the season...but really no more than that. Away from the site I called this game Disney World because it was like a fairy tale. After the first ten minutes or so, pretty much everything was easy and went Purdue's way. This isn't reality...this isn't at all like what the rest of the season will be.
Lots of improvement is still needed, but SEMO was a very poor barometer. UND won't be.
9 comments:
I disagree with the idea that Marve should be the starter, although I think that will be how it plays out. Purdue needs to have some continuity at the position; it could do wonders for them to have TerBush under center two years in a row. Purdue needs to develop a quarterback over several seasons to start being competitive, rather than just throwing in the least-injured guy every year.
First off, Marve is applying for a 6th year. Since he lost the majority of two seasons due to injury, he'll probably get the sixth season. If that happens, Marve and TerBush will both be Seniors in '12.
Then again, the NCAA's inconsistency knows no bounds.
Plus, TerBush was behind Henry coming into this season...He'll be back next year as well.
Second, the best player at the position needs to be on the field if his personality isn't a detriment to the team...and Marve, according to the players I've talked to has been a good/great teammate.
If you think TerBush is a better player, you're entitled to your opinion...but I don't see it that way.
I do think Marve should play by virtue of being best available, but I have a hard time believing he gets a 6th year. I feel like the NCAA wants to get everyone involved in the Miami stuff out of the NCAA and will consider his lack of punishment from that to be his 6th year. Obviously with Henry coming back next year, TerBush's development just isn't too important.
I agree that neither hit was dirty in that game and I definitely thought SEMO's hit was cleaner (if that makes sense) but that it was a pretty clear make up call. After calling it on Purdue, it would have been nearly impossible to not call it on SEMO
I have no idea why my name showed up like that...I'm Kevin
Thanks for weighing in, 09cae2c8-69cb...
Blogger is pretty awesome.
We all know that Notre Dame is going to put 30... probably 40 on the scoreboard. Their offense is for real. Hate them as we may, it's true. Even if they turn it over 2 or 3 times, they will still move the ball and light up the scoreboard.
I think rain would be our friend in this match up. Then we could run the ball and keep the game in the 20's score wise. I don't see us coming out on top in a shootout.
I would absolutely start Marve based on what I saw last Saturday. He is the guy that could go nuts on a "good, not great" team like ND.
Disagree about the dirty hits. Both were blatant helmet 2 helmet.
I noticed something different when Marve was playing: confidence and a command presence. Review the game film and watch whether or not the team responds different in the huddle when Marve is on the field. I think he's more confident and more of a leader. Talent aside, I think those are the things you need in a QB, especially when things are tight. Talent wise....I think he's the better QB. Don't think having a father who was a pro doesn't rub off on you.
Matt (and others) the NCAA has said that they don't want players putting their head down and leading with their head. Both players facemasks were up. Helmets made contact, but neither player speared the guy they were tackling...and both used their shoulders and arms to complete the hit.
It's a big boys game.
http://www.usatoday.com/sports/college/football/2009-09-28-helmet-hits_N.htm
Post a Comment